CSBA Daily News Roundup: November 18, 2026

STATE

EdSource: Who should California’s first education commissioner be? Experts weigh in

     One of Xavier Becerra’s first major tasks after taking office as governor on Jan. 4 will be to appoint the state’s first education commissioner, who will oversee a reorganization of the California Department of Education. EdSource surveyed more than a dozen California education leaders about the qualities Becerra should look for in an education commissioner and who might be capable of leading the effort to fix a system long considered fragmented and unresponsive to school districts’ needs. “We have a very diffused system. We need to coordinate it, organize it, point it in the right direction and get it to work,” said Linda Darling-Hammond, president of the California State Board of Education. That fragmented system is one reason Gov. Gavin Newsom and state legislators passed legislation in July to reorganize the department. The legislation followed a report by Policy Analysis for California Education recommending realigning roles and responsibilities to create a more coherent education governance system. “We have a history in our state of these really ambitious reforms that are adopted with very little state guidance and support,” said Julie Marsh, a co-author of the report. “We need someone to come in and make the department a place that can ensure consistent implementation across the state.”

     The education leaders surveyed came up with a list of top contenders that included state superintendents, county superintendents, a former deputy superintendent, a small charter school leader and the CEO of a nonprofit. Education leaders have a lengthy list of qualifications for the job, but nearly all agree that the new commissioner should have experience leading a complex organization, improving student academic outcomes and overseeing systemwide change. The person should also understand California’s complicated education system, know how to navigate Sacramento politics and build a strong relationship with the governor. Most of those interviewed by EdSource say the commissioner should have experience running a school district, preferably a large one, while also understanding the challenges facing smaller and rural districts.

FEDERAL

Education Week: Top House Democrat launches bid to undo Trump’s Education Department scramble

     The office that enforces federal civil rights laws in schools would move back to the U.S. Department of Education from the Justice Department under new legislation introduced by Rep. Bobby Scott of Virginia, the top Democrat on the U.S. House education committee. The measure is yet another sign that Democrats plan to use their newly won congressional control to fight back against the Trump administration’s moves to debilitate the agency by shifting its core offices to other parts of the federal bureaucracy. Over the past year-and-a-half, through a series of interagency agreements, Trump has sent at least 148 Education Department programs to six other Cabinet-level agencies.

     Title I grants to help schools educate disadvantaged students and career and technical education state grants have both moved to the U.S. Department of Labor, while special education oversight has been transferred to the Department of Health and Human Services. In June, the administration announced that the Office for Civil Rights — which is responsible for addressing complaints of civil rights violations at schools and colleges — would move to the Justice Department’s civil rights division. The Trump administration argued the transfer would “strengthen the federal government’s enforcement of federal civil rights laws in our nation’s schools” and would not “impact students, parents or families who believe they have experienced discrimination.” Former employees of both agencies, however, pointed to big structural differences between the two agencies.

ATTENDANCE

Education Week, commentary: Chronic absenteeism is worst for Native students. It’s no mystery why

     Native American students are missing school at rates that dwarf most states’ overall averages, according to data collected by the Associated Press for the 2022–23 school year. That disparity existed before the pandemic but then got worse, the Associated Press found. In half the 34 states studied, American Indian students were chronically absent at least 9 percentage points more than their home state’s average. In some states, most Native American children missed more than 10 percent of the school year, even as attendance improved for students of other backgrounds. In some states, the attendance gap between all students and Native American students grew by the end of the pandemic in 2023. For educational bureaucrats and academic researchers, these may seem like mere numbers on yet another chart. But for those of us leading Indian tribes across the country, this represents a painful reality. Far too many of our students are being left behind, and we risk losing their potential contributions to our people for generations to come.

     This is a fight the Poarch Band of Creek Indians knows all too well. In fact, we have struggled for equal educational access for decades. By the early 20th century, our children were barred entirely from the local public schools in the area known as Atmore, Alabama. They could not ride the county school bus. They were just not welcome. Poarch Creek families found their own ways to keep their children in school. In 1947, when a public school bus driver refused to pick up his twin daughters, Homer Jack Daughtry stood in the road until they were allowed to board, an act of courage that became a lasting symbol of the fight for equal rights faced by the Poarch Creek people and Native communities across the South. The chronic absenteeism data tell us that Native American children are still, in measurable and documented ways, on the outside of the American education promise.

TECHNOLOGY

Education Week: Anthropic agrees to protections for teachers who use Claude

     Anthropic announced Nov. 10 that it has adopted contractually enforceable safety and data-privacy standards for districts using its Claude for Teachers platform. The company agreed to allow school districts to adopt safety and privacy contract language developed for the National Academy for AI Instruction in New York City. The academy was created last July through a five-year, $23 million partnership between the nearly 1.9 million-member American Federation of Teachers and artificial intelligence (AI) developers Anthropic, Microsoft, and OpenAI.

     Claude for Teachers, launched this summer, provides a free (for this year, at least) account equivalent to the model’s chat, agentic, and coding tools for verified K-12 teachers, along with connected tools from other ed-tech vendors like Canva and MagicSchool. Anthropic’s move is intended to provide a “foundation for trust” for AI use among an increasingly skeptical educator corps, according to Elizabeth Kelly, Anthropic’s head of beneficial deployments.

Education Week: Fake AI images are targeting students and teachers. Schools aren’t prepared

     One in three educators don’t know if their school or district has a policy to address the potential threat to student safety from artificial intelligence (AI)-generated fake images and videos. That’s according to a nationwide survey of 852 educators by the EdWeek Research Center conducted this summer. A smaller share — 22 percent — said their school or district doesn’t have such a policy, and 2 percent of respondents said their district or school is “considering” creating one. The problem of what’s known as “deepfakes” — which could falsely feature an educator or student saying something offensive or appearing in a sexual manner — is growing in schools at a much faster pace than the enactment of policies to address their harm.

     Nationally, one in four K-12 students know someone who has been depicted in a nonconsensual and sexually explicit deepfake, according to a 2024 student survey by the Center for Democracy and Technology, a nonprofit that advocates for people’s rights online. The internet is now rife with simple and free-to-download AI tools that students can use to create and distribute fake images or videos of their peers or educators. Many are sexually explicit, targeting women or girls. Others threaten to damage reputations — for example, students have made fake videos of principals or other employees making racist or inappropriate remarks. School and district leaders should put together a plan of action before an incident occurs, rather than scrambling after the fact.

The 74: Phone bans improve learning, study finds — but so far, only slightly

     Recently enacted prohibitions on phone use in schools have produced slight, though recognizable, improvements in learning, according to a new study of millions of U.S. students. The paper’s authors argue that effective bans on devices during the school day could, over time, restore a substantial portion of the academic growth that has been lost over the past decade. But nagging questions remain about the efficacy of the bans, along with the wider impact of smartphones on children and adolescents. Given that most minors access their own devices frequently at home, even advocates for further restrictions concede that too little is known about the consequences of out-of-school use.

     The report was released Nov. 17 by academics at Harvard University and Dartmouth College, in collaboration with researchers from the testing organization NWEA. It is the first national study of in-school bans that makes use of student-level data, allowing educators and policy makers a more granular look at how academic outcomes have responded. The answer so far has been: incrementally. Schools that implemented strict bans, by requiring students to store their phones in lockable pouches, gained the equivalent of one to two weeks of additional instruction annually between 2022 and 2026. Measured differently, that’s about an extra two minutes per hour of class time.

LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCIES

Marin Independent Journal: Convicted former Marin superintendent denies molesting second student suing small Sonoma County school district

     Two days after a former Marin County superintendent began a jail sentence for a child molestation conviction, he was named in a sexual battery and negligence lawsuit accusing him of similar activity while working at a Sonoma County elementary school near Petaluma. Robert Raines, 73, has since been released from jail after serving time for his misdemeanor conviction in Marin County Superior Court. He’s representing himself in the lawsuit filed in July and denied the allegations in a response he filed Oct. 15 in Sonoma County Superior Court. “The complaint fails to state a claim upon which relief can be granted,” Raines wrote in his answer to the filing.

     The lawsuit was filed by a former Wilson Elementary School student, John Doe, who is now 31 years old and says he was abused in 2004 while Raines was principal. Doe’s attorney, Sean Riordan, told The Press Democrat that Doe is not the same Wilson Elementary student who testified in Raines’ criminal trial in Marin County Superior Court. At the time, Raines was on trial over allegations he molested a Shoreline Unified School District employee’s child in 2021 while he was superintendent. A jury convicted him in November 2023 and a judge issued a 210-day jail sentence and ordered the former educator to register as a sex offender. Raines began his jail sentence in July and his actual time behind bars was cut in half once credits were taken into account.

Education Week: Mud pies and monkey bars: Inside a transitional kindergarten built for play

     It’s a picture-perfect fall morning in this Northern California town, and the youngest students at Laurel School Lower Campus are taking full advantage of it during their lengthy recess. The swing sets are in heavy rotation. One 4-year-old, legs pumping vigorously, soars high above her peers. On the monkey bars, a girl hangs for what seems like an eternity, her legs dangling. Seven or eight students, mostly boys, zip around a paved surface on three-wheeled bicycles. And in a muddy sand pit, children take turns pumping water from a freestanding, commercial-size water dispenser. Two girls announce that they’re making dinner with their wet globs of sand, much of which oozes down the front of their clothes. They don’t seem to notice as they make their way to the nearby play kitchen.

     This fall marks the fourth year of Laurel’s transitional kindergarten, or TK, program. In-house expertise in early childhood education and a physical layout conducive to very young children made this elementary school an optimal site for the Menlo Park City school district to pilot TK — which is free for all California residents who turn 4 by Sept. 1. Policymakers in California and other states that have added universal pre-K for 4-year-olds see this transitional grade between preschool and kindergarten as an antidote to declining student enrollment in public schools — blamed largely on falling birth rates, increases in school choice, and strict immigration policies. It’s an alternate solution to laying off teachers or closing facilities, says Hanna Melnick, senior policy adviser and director of early learning policy at the Learning Policy Institute. In California, about 52 percent of eligible children are now enrolled in TK, and the state expects enrollment to continue growing. 

The Modesto Bee: Modesto teachers vote to strike if necessary. Here’s what happened during 1980 strike

     A strike vote by the Modesto Teachers Association (MTA) found 97 percent support in a turnout by more than 94 percent of the union’s members, MTA President Jennifer McGrath announced Nov. 5, the day of the vote, “1,300 people rolled through that parking lot at Downey” to make their voices heard, she said in a Vimeo video.

     In response to the vote, Modesto City Schools issued a statement that reads, in part, “Modesto Teachers Association’s strike authorization vote does not mean teachers will go on strike. California law prohibits teachers from striking until a neutral third-party fact-finding report is released.” It goes on to say the decision to authorize a strike “is not in the best interest of students, staff, families, and the broader Modesto community. The District is concerned and alarmed by the implications of MTA’s strike authorization given that this action will be detrimental to relationships, operations, and improvement work for years to come. While the District has worked intentionally to foster trust, respect, and collaboration with educators, a strike will only set us back. We need to adopt approaches that cultivate collective ownership and unity, not division.”

Los Angeles Times: First a death, then hoax threats. Attendance plunged after Franklin High tragedy, data reveal

     After a student’s on-campus death, attendance at Franklin High School declined sharply — with nearly two-thirds of students staying home — then declined again after two false alarms, underscoring the trauma that students and families are working through, newly released data reveal. In a separate development, family members of the 17-year-old student who died announced through attorneys have filed claims for damages, which is typically a precursor to a lawsuit, against the Los Angeles Unified School District. On Sept. 30, Xavier Nungaray-Martinez was repeatedly hit in a classroom by another student before running out the door, then plunging over a fourth-floor railing as it appeared that the student who hit him was rapidly approaching. All of that was captured on cellphone video that has circulated widely but does not capture the entire sequence of events.

     The day of Xavier’s death, the head count at Franklin High was 1,010, with about 92 percent of students attending. The next day, 407 students came to school, for an attendance rate of about 37 percent. The following day, it was 399 students. The third day out, Oct. 5, attendance had mostly recovered, with 987 students, or about 91 percent, present. But the space to breathe did not last. On Oct. 8, a student reported that another student said he had a gun, according to district sources. That same day, an anonymous threatening call came in, which was determined to be a hoax. The school, located in Highland Park, went on lockdown that morning until administrators determined there was no danger. Early the next day came another scare, this time due to rumors of a mass shooting threat, which police determined was not credible. Each time, Principal Marine Davtyan sent a message to parents’ phones and computers stating that the threat had been checked out and no danger was found. On Oct. 9, attendance crashed again, with 447 students, or about 41 percent, coming to school.