Articles below are meant to inform members of significant reporting and commentary on public schools and do not necessarily reflect the views of CSBA. (Please note: Included in this email are articles on news sites that have limited access for nonsubscribers.)
LEGAL
The California Department of Education (CDE) informed students and families last month that demographic information, residential addresses and disability records of millions of students had been compromised in a massive data breach that occurred over four months this year. Now, a former public school student is suing the department for failing to protect his data and that of others like him. The department contracts with private company Educational Testing Service (ETS) to provide assessment services for all students enrolled at public schools in the state. Between May and September, hackers used a compromised login credential to access a website that ETS used to exchange student assessment information with CDE. The New Jersey-based company identified the problem on Sept. 25. By then, the information of current and former students enrolled in California public schools between 2023 and now had been accessed and copied.
“The data breach has caused plaintiff considerable stress and anxiety, including many late-night hours spent researching the incident and trying to determine how to protect himself,” says the lawsuit filed in Sacramento Superior Court on Nov. 2 by former student Dane Wilson. “Plaintiff is most concerned about the exposure of his disability information, sensitive information about his health and educational history that he did not choose to share with defendants and that can never be changed or retrieved.” The proposed class action lawsuit, filed against the department and ETS, seeks reforms in the cybersecurity infrastructure to prevent future harm as well as damages of an unspecified amount. The CDE said it would not comment on pending litigation. This is not the first lawsuit filed over the data breach. A parent of two current elementary students teamed up with a former student in October to sue ETS in federal court over alleged negligence in handling personally identifiable information and protected health data.
TECHNOLOGY
A subtle, but significant, vibe shift has taken hold across California’s classrooms this semester. Students are making fewer screen swipes. Dings and buzzes aren’t disrupting class discussions as often. Teachers say classrooms feel more alive with face-to-face interactions. A 2024 law required all school districts, county offices of education and charter schools to approve policies limiting or prohibiting student smartphone use by July 1. The state law, known as the Phone-Free Schools Act, gave local control in deciding those restrictions. As a result, policies vary widely from district to district and, in some cases, from school to school. Some schools require students to lock their phones away the entire day; others allow them during lunch and between classes, while some leave much of the enforcement to teachers. The overall effects, so far, have been profound and far-reaching, educators say.
EdSource reporters interviewed more than 40 people in seven school districts across the state about their schools’ cellphone policies, and analyzed the written policies of the largest 15 districts. School leaders and teachers said they are seeing higher student engagement inside classrooms. Educators at some schools are reporting fewer fights and bullying since their policies went into effect. Some also said they have seen improvements in academic performance and overall well-being, though researchers caution it is too early to know whether those changes can be directly attributed to cellphone crackdowns. A patchwork of approaches is to be expected, given the diversity of California’s school districts, said Troy Flint, chief of communications for the California School Boards Association. Flint said some parents have pushed for students to have more access because they want to be able to contact their children during emergencies. “That’s really been the rub,” Flint said. “How (do) we restrict access to cellphones in a way that complies with the law and supports a more productive learning atmosphere, but still allows students to have access in emergency situations or situations where the student is more reliant on parental connection to help them navigate the day.”
FEDERAL
Education Week: Senate GOP proposes steady education funding, setting up budget showdown
A group of Republican senators has unveiled a spending package that preserves virtually all current federal funding for education for the 2027–28 school year — setting up the next phase of a budget battle that could be resolved within the next month or stretch into the new year. The Republican-led Senate appropriations committee on Nov. 16 released an education spending proposal that would keep level, year-over-year investments in key K-12 formula programs like Title I for low-income students and Title III for English learners. Funding would increase slightly for special education services, career technical education programs, rural schools, and Head Start early childhood centers. Virtually all existing competitive education grant programs would continue, with most maintaining their current funding levels or fluctuating slightly.
The new federal fiscal year started Oct. 1, but spending is currently frozen at last year’s levels until Dec. 11 — at which point Congress has to either finalize fiscal 2027 spending levels or extend the deadline even further. Without a deal, federal agencies without a finalized budget would have to shut down, as they did for 43 days last fall. For education, the budget process will entail reconciling major differences between the Senate appropriations bill and the one House Republicans advanced this summer. That House bill proposed to cut more than $1 billion in annual Title I funding, eliminate more than a dozen competitive education grant programs, and zero out federal investment in English learner services.
TEACHING AND LEARNING
Schools spend years teaching algebra, chemistry and history to students. Yet too many finish high school without knowing how memory, attention and stress impact their learning. They assume that poor grades mean “they aren’t smart enough.” The truth is, few students are taught evidence-backed strategies for studying, getting a good night’s sleep and managing stress before high-pressure exams. If schools and teachers want students to thrive, they must teach them how to learn early on. Case in point: My high school classmate pulled an all-nighter before an Advanced Placement U.S. History exam at Lithonia High School in metropolitan Atlanta, cramming Heimler’s History videos. During the test, he forgot much of the content he had studied. His conclusion was clear: “Maybe I should’ve studied harder.” I disagreed. The issue wasn’t his effort. Nor his intelligence. It was that he had never been taught how learning worked.
This is a significant issue for students in under-resourced communities, where access to guidance on how stress, sleep and attention affect learning is often limited. Many students are left to figure out effective strategies on their own. I saw this firsthand at my school. It’s why I started the Cognition Club in ninth grade with the support of my counselor. As the club developed, we discussed foods that support concentration and strategies for managing stress while studying for the state-required Georgia Milestones Assessment — topics rarely addressed in class. My interest in brain health came from home. My sister developed epilepsy when she was 9, and her grades slipped over time as it affected her memory, concentration and ability to attend school.
The 74: Fewer than half of states require K-12 Native American education
Cammie DuPuis-Pablo had reached her breaking point. For years, her two sons had been bullied at school because of their Native American heritage. They were called girls because of their long, dark braids. They were taunted with racist remarks and got into fights. The underlying reason, she felt, was a lack of knowledge and education about Indigenous history and culture in the Missoula County Public Schools — even though the Montana district is mere miles away from the Flathead Reservation. “They might have had one section [about Native Americans] throughout the year, but I would have to correct things, and that was frustrating for me, especially because our reservation is right here,” she said. “I was frustrated that I was having to correct things from educators while my boys were really trying to be cultural and live that way.”
Especially frustrating was that a 1999 law, the Indian Education for All Act, required local Native American history and cultural heritage be taught to all Montana K-12 students — nearly 30 years after a similar commitment had been written into the state Constitution. A 2004 lawsuit and a follow-up report a decade later both failed to get districts statewide to incorporate Native instruction. A lack of Indigenous education contributes to stereotypes, such as the idea that Native Americans are a thing of the past, partly because curricula commonly end in the 1900s, according to Columbia University researchers. But there are 575 federally recognized tribes in the U.S. and 334 reservations located across 35 states. Many other tribal nations don’t have reservations, and some are still fighting for federal recognition. Today, nearly a half-million U.S. K-12 students are American Indian or Alaska Native, according to the National Indian Education Association — a number that experts say may be a significant undercount.
LOCAL EDUCATIONAL AGENCIES
After enduring ongoing financial challenges and the first teachers strike in its history earlier this year, West Contra Costa Unified School District leaders had reason to worry about whether they could persuade voters to renew a $10.2 million parcel tax measure. Passage of a parcel tax — so named because it levies a fixed amount per square foot on each “parcel” of real estate in a community — requires getting a two-thirds majority at the ballot box. Instead, Measure V is winning comfortably with 75.3 percent of the vote, as of the Nov. 13 tally. (Results will be officially certified on Dec. 3.)
Across the state, school districts such as West Contra Costa have sought voters’ approval for parcel tax measures to ensure a steady source of funding for a range of educational services (unlike bond measures, which typically are for new construction or renovations). The district’s elected board says Measure V will provide a renewed source of funding for programs such as science, music, career and technical education, school libraries and counseling, as well as the ability to attract and retain qualified teachers. Of the $10.2 million the measure will raise, $2 million would go to support charter schools in the district. The victory offers a case study in how a school district can successfully get a parcel tax approved, even at a time when voters are dealing with record high gas prices and rising costs on multiple other fronts.
The Sacramento Bee: State superintendent to select Sac City Unified budget review committee
After the state did not provide the additional candidates for a budget review committee the district had requested, Sacramento City Unified School District’s (SCUSD) board again declined Nov. 16 to choose from the original list. State law now requires State Superintendent Tony Thurmond select the committee members. The development came days after the board declined to select candidates from the state’s original list, citing six candidates’ ties to Fiscal Crisis and Management Assistance Team (FCMAT) and saying the group could not provide the independent review the district wanted. The budget review committee will review the district’s revised budget and recommend whether it should be approved or revised. “This budget review committee process has the ability to truly help us stabilize our budget and not just repeat the work that’s already been done by [Sacramento County Office of Education] and FCMAT,” said Taylor Kayatta, a board member of the district. “And for that reason, I do think that the list does not provide us with names that will allow that independent review.”
FCMAT is a state-funded agency that evaluates school districts’ finances and identifies fiscal problems. Officials from FCMAT and the Sacramento County Office of Education, SCUSD’s fiscal overseer, have been at odds with the district over how to address its fiscal crisis. After receiving the list from the California Department of Education on Nov. 9, the SCUSD board had until Nov. 16 to select three committee members. During the Nov. 16 special board meeting, Chief Business Officer Gerardo Castillo said the district had not received additional names and presented the original list of nine again.
Marin Independent Journal: Novato schools OK $2.63M in cuts
Novato Unified School District took the first step this week to close a $6.5 million budget gap by Dec. 15. Trustees voted unanimously Nov. 17 in favor of making $1.32 million in budget reductions related to staffing. The vote authorizes the issuance of $1.32 million in preliminary layoff warning notices to the equivalent of roughly 18 full-time positions. An additional $1.31 million in cuts were detailed in the Nov. 17 reports for discretionary program reductions recommended by district management. This brings the total authorized reductions to $2.63 million. The $2.63 million package was the first of a three-phase reductions plan to close the $6.5 million budget shortfall starting in 2027–28. Phases two and three of the cuts are scheduled for Dec. 1 and Dec. 15. “The $2.63 million is a running total, as we are trying to hit $6.5 million,” said Joshua Braff, chief finance officer.
If all three phases are approved by the board, the district will have a balanced and positive budget status by Dec. 15, the deadline for the first interim report to Marin County Office of Education for the current 2026–27 school year and two years out. A positive budget status is declared, in general, if school districts have at least a 3 percent fund balance, or reserves. Novato Unified’s policy is to maintain 16.67 percent in reserves so as to have two months of operating expenses available in the case of an emergency, Braff said. By approving all three phases of cuts, the district intends to achieve positive budget status. “This item itself has no immediate fiscal impact, but formalizes the district’s plan to achieve fiscal solvency,” Braff said in a staff report.
Pasadena Unified School District Superintendent Elizabeth Blanco’s proposed district transformation process would allow the next four graduating classes to remain at their current high schools before any potential district redesigns would take effect, according to district documents. Blanco, on Nov. 19, will be presenting a five-step district transformation process in the final regular meeting before the board of education’s post-election makeup changes. That process — which could involved school mergers or closures — seeks to avoid the kind of problems that developed earlier this year, when a push to merge district schools devolved into controversy and a trustee recall process that created widespread mistrust in the district among stakeholders.
“District staff developed a comprehensive process designed to support the long-term sustainability of the Pasadena Unified School District while improving educational opportunities and outcomes for students,” according to a report prepared by Blanco’s staff. But the same problems that fueled the district’s school consolidation process persist: Declining enrollment, a serious problem for many public districts, is at the root of fiscal issues that are forcing the Pasadena district to find ways to “transform,” a process that Blanco is trying to define and shape at the behest of the board of education.

