Globally, student performance declined sharply after the onset of the pandemic, following a long period of stagnation and slow decline, including in the U.S. What’s unique about American schools is the widening gap between its highest- and lowest-scoring students, according to new research from the Brookings Institution examining trends and global comparisons in education.
Findings from the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP), Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA) and the Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) show test score gaps by race, ethnicity and socioeconomic status remain large and “are not narrowing at a pace sufficient to close them in the foreseeable future,” according to the report. Meanwhile, scores for the lowest-performing students (10th percentile) have dropped sharply over the last decade, while scores for the highest performers (90th percentile) have held steady.
This 90-10 gap has widened far more rapidly in the U.S. than in peer countries — and now stands out in international comparisons.
“Far too many U.S. students are falling well behind their higher-achieving peers, and this pattern looks substantially worse in the U.S. than in its peer countries, the report states. “Addressing this must be a priority for leaders in education and public policy.”
In 2024, CSBA began laying the groundwork for the SOS for Student Achievement: Close the State Accountability Gap campaign. Backed by research, the approach calls for greater focus, alignment, efficiency and support in state operations, creating conditions conducive to success for local educational agencies across California so that they are better able to support students and close these achievement gaps.
Additional findings
Researchers found that while widening achievement gaps present a significant and urgent challenge, it’s not the only area of immediate concern.
“The U.S. is also an outlier in youth well-being and mental health — a problem that predates the pandemic, has grown more serious since, and requires a concerted response of its own,” the report states. “In fact, in international comparisons, the United States looks considerably worse on measures of mental health than measures of academic performance.”
Alongside its assessments, PISA surveys 15-year-olds on a wide range of topics, including their perceptions of school, experiences outside school and time use.
According to the report, 15-year-olds in the U.S. continue to rank near the bottom of Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries on PISA’s measure of well-being.
“They stand out in how often they report feeling like outsiders, out of place, and lonely at school. This is consistent with other measures that indicate very high rates of youth depression and student disengagement in the U.S.,” researchers wrote. “American students are also outliers in the amount of time they report spending on social media and playing video games relative to 15-year-olds in peer countries.”

