The State Board of Education’s (SBE) Nov. 12 meeting included the adoption of the state’s new Local Control and Accountability Plan (LCAP) template for the 2027–28 through 2029–30 school years, deep dives into topics related to assessment and accountability and presentations from student leaders on topics that impact their education and futures.
The final meeting of the year was also the last for State Superintendent of Public Instruction Tony Thurmond. “You’ve been a creative and consistent force for improving our California schools. The initiatives to highlight literacy, to recruit and retain a diverse teaching force, and to support Black student achievement have been much needed and greatly appreciated,” said SBE President Linda Darling-Hammond. “I’ve greatly valued our partnership and collaboration over the years.”
New LCAP template
California’s LCAP is a three-year plan that describes LEAs’ goals, actions, services and expenditures to support positive student outcomes that address state and local priorities. The document provides an opportunity for districts to share their stories of how, what and why programs and services are selected to meet the specific needs of their students and community.
The SBE adopted the proposed revisions to the LCAP template and instructions presented by the California Department of Education (CDE), which incorporated feedback provided by the board during its Sept. 9 meeting.
Among the provisions discussed during the September meeting and adopted by the SBE for the final template are changing the word “Red,” currently used in the LCAP instructions, to “the lowest performance level” to align with the language of Education Code Section 52064, as well as requiring that local educational agencies include specific actions in their LCAP to address all instances where a school or student group received the lowest performance level on one or more state indicators on the California School Dashboard. Specifically, LEAs must include required actions in the 2027–28 LCAP to address instances when a school or student group receives the lowest performance level on the Science Indicator, English Language Arts (ELA) Growth Indicator, and/or Mathematics Growth Indicator in addition to the state indicators available on the California School Dashboard.
During public comment, CSBA Legislative Advocate Carlos Machado said that while CSBA supports the proposed changes to the LCAP template and instructions, there is still more to do ensure the LCAP is a driver of student achievement rather than a burdensome task.
“Our recent statewide outreach with district and county leaders underscores a broader reality that over the years the LCAP has grown from a more concise, community-facing planning tool into an unwieldy compliance document; in many cases, exceeding hundreds of pages. Districts are often required to build parallel summaries just to communicate with families,” Machado explained. “Through our ongoing interviews and focus groups, CSBA is actively identifying template fixes and longer-term legislative reforms to reduce duplication, streamline reporting and return time to educators. We ask you to adopt this item today, and CSBA looks forward to partnering closely with the board, CDE and state policymakers to make the LCAP a simpler, more accessible tool for local school communities.”
CDE staff said the department will provide statewide trainings related to the LCAP requirements via its “Tuesday @ 2” webinars between Nov. 17, 2026, and Jan. 19, 2027.
Assessment and accountability
The board reviewed results of the 2026 California School Dashboard and 2025–26 California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) results, released on Oct. 15. This year was the first time that Dashboard and CAASPP results have been published on the same day, reflecting the SBE’s decision to provide LEAs and other education decision-makers with the full picture of student outcomes.
Reactions largely echoed those of prior years: Lauding the progress made and recent investments while recognizing that there is much more work to do to improve student achievement.
Overall, graduation rates hit a 10-year high — 88.1 percent — while suspension and chronic absenteeism rates continued to decrease. However, the 2025–26 CAASPP scores indicate:
- Progress is slowing. After gains of 1.8 points in each subject in 2024–25, this year’s increases were by just 0.5 points in ELA and 1.1 points in math.
- Math has recovered more than ELA. Math is 1.4 points below 2019 after falling about 6 points by 2022. ELA is 1.6 points below after falling about 4 points.
- Gaps remain large. Black and Latino students gained the most this year, yet Black and Latino students still trail white students by 22 to 30 points and trail Asian students by 34 to 49 points. Additionally, students from higher-income households outperform those from lower-income households by about 30 points. Black students are the only major group above 2019 in both subjects.
“We cannot confuse modest improvement with meaningful, sustained and impactful progress,” CSBA CEO & Executive Director Vernon M. Billy said in a statement. “When the rise in graduation rates far exceeds growth in student performance, it suggests more and more graduates have paper credentials without the level of knowledge, we, as a state, have deemed optimal to prepare them for success after high school.” Read the full statement here and CSBA’s analysis of the results here.
The board also moved forward on the development of a positive point scale for the ELA and Math Indicators on the 2027 Dashboard in an effort to transition to a clearer, more accessible measure than Distance from Proficiency (DFP).
The current DFP methodology represents the “distance” between a student’s score on the CAASPP and the Proficient Achievement Level threshold (the lowest threshold scale score for Level 3). An average DFP (or an average of all the distances) is calculated at the LEA, school and student group levels, then used to determine the performance levels (e.g. colors on the Dashboard).
According to the American Institutes for Research (AIR), which performed a comprehensive review for the SBE of how states report academic achievement using scale scores, an LEA in California can improve its performance and still receive a negative value because of the way DFP Is calculated, which can create confusion about whether it is making progress.
Discussion during AIR’s presentation to the board focused on three states: Colorado and Massachusetts, which utilize a mean scale score, and Connecticut, which utilizes a scale score index that transforms student scale scores onto a common, positive scale and then averages the scores across grade levels. In all three states, the metric is expressed on a positive scale, with no negative values.
In California, transitioning to a positive point scale would rescale each student’s existing CAASPP scale score into a value that would be used to calculate the average performance displayed for schools, LEAs and student groups on ELA and math Dashboard indicators.
“Virtually all the other scales we use in education are positive points scales,” Darling-Hammond noted. “Grades are often calculated on a scale from 0 to 100. People have common understandings of the idea that perhaps a 90 or better commonly means an A. On the current scale, however, zero means proficient. And so, everything below that is a negative number. No other state currently reports their summit of test data in this way.”
Representing achievement via distance from proficiency has led to confusion in the field and even media coverage incorrectly reporting that a “negative score” means that students are below grade level, she said.
“The question ahead of us is whether and how to transform the way these scores are reported, so they’re positive and easier to understand,” Darling-Hammond continued. “Just to be clear, this would not change what is being measured … the underlying measure and methodology, and what it tells us about student performance would stay the same. The standards are the same.”
SBE Vice President Cynthia Glover Woods called the discussion “a positive step in the right direction,” but noted that implementation will be critical in ensuring such a change meets the board’s goals to make results easier to understand.
“Anytime we can frame things positively, as opposed to negatively, I think it helps in the conversations,” Glover Woods said. “But how we go about doing it really lays out whether this is something that lands well, or whether it’s something that creates a whole lot of other issues that then have to be dealt with.”
In other SBE news:
- The board announced its selection of three SBE student member finalists for submission to Gov. Gavin Newsom for consideration and appointment for 2027–28. The finalists — Adit Bathla of Monte Vista High School in San Ramon Valley Unified School District; Ethan Shapiro of University High School in Irvine USD; and Rishi Sikh of Westlake High School in the Conejo Valley USD — were selected by the board’s screening committee from an initial set of 12 semi-finalists.
- The board approved a 15-day public comment period open for a proposal that introduces an alternative to the current 20-day Extended School Year schedule of no fewer than 15 instructional days, provided that specific instructional time thresholds are met. CDE staff noted that the change would not reduce instructional time but gives LEAs flexibility in program design while ensuring students continue to receive the instructional time necessary to support their individualized education program goals.
- Student delegates of the 2026 Student Advisory Board on Education brought to the State Board seven key issues researched and examined during their Nov. 10-12 conference, including standardizing college and career readiness resources; requiring the implementation of a mental health unit for grades 9-12; developing a four-year voluntary pilot program to study student-reliance on artificial intelligence; and providing students an informational card written in both Spanish and English that details one’s rights when interacting with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and provides additional resources; as well as efforts to expand extracurricular offerings, boost civic and financial literacy and close achievement gaps driven by socioeconomic factors.
- The board approved phase two of the CDE’s three-phase effort to update the Career Technical Education Model Curriculum Standards. Phase two includes five career clusters — Education; Energy and Natural Resources; Financial Services; Hospitality, Events, and Tourism; and Public Service and Safety — which have been updated to reflect the new career cluster names and California pathway structure.
- The board approved the proposed next phase development plan for California Science Test mini performance tasks. The full timeline is available in attachment one of the agenda item.
The next State Board meeting is scheduled for Jan. 13-14. View the full meeting calendar.

